Value goes to whoever makes the change happen
Startups do well when a shift is underway and incumbents are slow to move. Forcing a shift that has not arrived is a different bet.
By precipitating change, you’ll create value. Those that do this best will win.
By 2010 Apple’s App Store held hundreds of thousands of apps, and its built-in search matched mostly on app names. A user looking for something to track running routes had to know what the app was called. Ben Keighran’s company, Chomp, launched that year in San Francisco with a search engine that tried to find apps by what they did. The line is credited to him, though the talk or interview it came from has not been traced, and his company illustrates it well. The change in how people found software was already underway, because the stores were growing much faster than their tools. Chomp’s bet was to push that change forward before the platform owners did it themselves. The risk in that bet is plain: the owner of the store can improve its own search at any time, and a company built on someone else’s platform lives at that owner’s pace.
“Precipitate” is a strong word. It means to cause something to happen suddenly, often sooner than it would have. The line is saying that value goes to the companies that make a shift happen, rather than those that wait for it. That fits many cases: online payments before banks built them well, cheap web hosting before large providers noticed small customers, digital music stores while record labels hesitated. In each, the shift was coming, and the company that moved first collected much of the value.
The idea breaks down in two ways. The first is timing. A change forced before its conditions exist tends to fail expensively. Webvan spent heavily on online grocery delivery from 1999 and went bankrupt in 2001, before broadband and consumer habits had caught up with the idea. Precipitating change works on something already moving; it cannot create the movement alone.
The second is who the change lands on. A company can precipitate change for its users against their wishes, such as a redesign, a new fee or a changed policy. Sometimes that is right and the complaints fade. Sometimes it drives the users away, and the value created goes to a competitor who kept the old way.
The honest version, then, is narrower than the line. Find a change that is already happening, where incumbents are slow, and push it along faster than they can. That is where precipitating creates value. Forcing a change the world has not asked for is closer to a gamble.