Skip to the page

Plainly Put

One sentence about building things, taken apart

HomeExecution

Simple answers come at the end of the thinking

A one-line strategy is worth something only when it can refuse a profitable-looking opportunity.

The essence of profound insight is simplicity.

Jim Collins

Archilochus, a Greek poet of the seventh century BC, left a fragment contrasting the fox, who knows many things, with the hedgehog, who knows one big thing. Isaiah Berlin borrowed the image in 1953 to sort writers by temperament. Jim Collins borrowed it again for Good to Great (2001), and the sentence above comes from the chapter he built around it. The companies in his study that made a lasting jump in results had each boiled their strategy down to a single organizing idea, and then declined whatever fell outside it.

Collins arrived at that idea through three questions asked together: what a company could be the best in the world at, what actually drove its economics, and what its people cared about. The plain statement sat where the answers overlapped. His best-known case is Walgreens, which settled on being the most convenient drugstore and measured itself by profit per customer visit. That one measure explained decisions that looked strange from the outside, such as packing stores tightly into a city, paying to move them onto better corner sites, and leaving the restaurant business the family had run for decades.

The word that carries the sentence is “profound”. A short statement is cheap, and nearly every company has one printed somewhere. Collins reported that his companies needed about four years on average to reach theirs, through argument, failed attempts and a lot of looking at numbers they did not like. The simplicity was what remained after the understanding had been compressed. A founder who writes a one-line strategy in the first week has written a slogan, which is a different thing and a perfectly useful one, but it has not yet been earned.

A practical test follows from this. A statement that reflects real insight makes decisions on its own. It tells a small software company to turn down the large customer who wants a custom build, or tells a shop to stop stocking the product line that sells but eats floor space. Southwest Airlines ran for decades on a short idea of cheap, frequent, point-to-point flights, and the idea explained why it flew a single aircraft type and avoided the hub airports its rivals built around. If a strategy line cannot say no to anything, it is decoration.

The line also has a weak side, and Collins’s own list shows it. Two of his eleven companies were in serious trouble within a few years of the book: Circuit City filed for bankruptcy in November 2008 and was liquidated, and Fannie Mae was placed under government conservatorship in September 2008. A clear idea can outlive the conditions that made it true, and the clarity makes it harder to notice when that happens. Phil Rosenzweig’s The Halo Effect (2007) raised a deeper objection: studies that pick companies by past success and then look for shared traits tend to find tidy explanations, because success makes everything a company did look deliberate.

None of that makes simplicity wrong. It makes it provisional. The simple answer is the best summary of what a company currently understands, and it deserves to be rewritten when the understanding changes. Collins sets out the framework in his summary of the Hedgehog Concept, and the three questions are still a good way to spend an afternoon with a co-founder.