Skip to the page

Plainly Put

One sentence about building things, taken apart

HomeExecution

Small companies win with attention, not muscle

How Taobao beat eBay in China, and why the same story shows the limits of cleverness without capital.

When you are small, you have to be very focused and rely on your brain, not your strength.

Jack Ma

In 2003 eBay bought out EachNet, then China’s leading auction site, and looked set to own online trading in the country. Alibaba answered the same year with Taobao, a consumer marketplace that charged sellers nothing to list. eBay had more money, a global brand and a proven model. By the end of 2006 it had folded its Chinese site into a joint venture with a local partner and was, for practical purposes, out of the market.

That contest is the clearest illustration of what Jack Ma means. A small company cannot win by doing what the large one does, only harder. It lacks the budget and the patient shareholders who can absorb years of losses. What it can do is study the market more carefully than the incumbent bothers to, and pick one point where the bigger player’s strength turns into a weakness. Listing fees were eBay’s revenue, so matching a free rival would have cost it the very thing it came for. Taobao also built its site around how Chinese buyers and sellers actually traded, with chat between the two parties and, from 2004, Alipay holding the money until the goods arrived. None of that needed more force. It needed knowledge of the customer.

Focus is the other half of the sentence, and in practice the harder half. Small teams are tempted to chase every opportunity because each one looks like survival. The result is several half-built products and not one good enough to beat anybody. Focus means deciding which customer and which problem matter this year and letting the rest go, even when the rest includes revenue.

The line has limits, and Ma’s own story shows them. Free listings were paid for by someone. SoftBank and a group of other investors put $82 million into Alibaba in 2004, and in 2005 Yahoo invested $1 billion for a large stake. The brain chose the strategy; money kept it alive long enough to work. A small company with a clever idea and no capital can still lose to a slower rival that simply outlasts it.

There are also markets where strength decides almost everything. A mobile network, a car plant or an airline needs capital before cleverness has any room to operate. China’s group-buying rush of 2010 and 2011, with thousands of sites copying Groupon within months, has so far looked more like a spending contest than a contest of ideas.

Size changes the advice as well. Once a company is large it has strength, and the danger flips: big firms tend to stop thinking because they can afford to. The sentence is addressed to the small, but the large could use it.

For a founder the useful test is short. List the places where the company now competes on resources, such as advertising spend, headcount, or price cuts funded by losses. Each is a place where a better funded rival can crush it. Then list the places where it competes on understanding: what it knows about its customers that nobody else has bothered to learn. The second list is where a small company can actually win.