Owners who answer to no one still benefit from answering to someone
Nobody can fire a sole owner. That is exactly why a regular appointment with someone who asks hard questions is worth arranging.
It’s a great discipline to have to report to somebody, even if you’re the sole owner.
Tim O’Reilly described this lesson in a 2010 interview with Inc. magazine. A management consultant had told him to set up a board of directors for O’Reilly Media, even though he controlled the company and nobody could force him to. The point was not governance in the legal sense. It was having to explain himself, on a schedule, to people who would notice if the explanation did not hold up.
Reporting does several useful things at once. It forces the numbers to be gathered and looked at, which sole owners often postpone. It forces priorities to be written down, because a board meeting needs an agenda. And it creates a moment when a plan from three months ago is compared with what actually happened. Without that moment, a founder can drift for a year while each week feels busy.
The discipline does not require a formal board. A small business owner can get most of it from two or three experienced people who agree to read a short monthly update and meet each quarter. Some founders pair up with another founder and exchange updates. The only requirement is that the other person reads it, remembers last month, and asks.
It fails in two opposite ways. A board made of friends who approve everything provides the ritual without the discipline. A board with real power can do the reverse, and remove the founder: Apple’s board sided against Steve Jobs in 1985, and he left the company he started. Sole owners who add outside directors should be clear about which kind of board they are building.
For most small companies the first failure is far more common than the second. The test of a reporting arrangement is simple: in the last year, did anyone on the other side of the table change a decision? If the answer is never, the owner is still reporting to nobody, only more politely. The fix is to invite at least one person who has run a similar business and is known for saying no.