Skip to the page

Plainly Put

One sentence about building things, taken apart

HomeFounders and teams

Creative work needs room to fail, and a reason to stop

Polaroid's founder built a company on attempts that were allowed to fail. Late in his career, the same confidence kept a doomed product going.

An essential aspect of creativity is not being afraid to fail.

Edwin Land

In 1943 Edwin Land’s young daughter asked why she could not see a photograph right after he took it. Four years later Land demonstrated a camera that produced a finished print in about a minute, and Polaroid began selling it in 1948. Between the question and the camera lay a long run of chemistry that did not work. Land often pointed out that scientists had given themselves permission to fail by calling their attempts experiments, so that a failure counted as information rather than disgrace. His line about creativity says the same thing more briefly.

It holds wherever the answer cannot be found by planning. A new chemical process, a new kind of product or a new piece of writing usually needs many attempts, most of which do not work. A person or team afraid of failing will stop early, choose safe variations and never find the thing that required ten wrong tries first. Polaroid under Land ran on that tolerance for most of four decades.

The same company shows the cost. In 1977 Polaroid launched Polavision, an instant home movie system that Land championed personally. The films were short, silent and dim, and they arrived just as video cassette recorders were becoming available to households. Sales were poor, and in 1979 the company wrote off tens of millions of dollars on the product. A few years later Land left the company he had founded.

Polavision was not a failure of fear. It was a failure of feedback. The confidence that let Land keep trying in the lab also let him push a product past the point where the market had answered. In a lab, a failed experiment is cheap and its result is plain. In a launched product, failure is expensive and easy to explain away.

The useful reading is to separate the two stages. While exploring, fear of failure is the enemy, and attempts should be cheap and plentiful. Once a product is in front of customers, the goal is to notice failure quickly and act on it, which requires some respect for it.