Skip to the page

Plainly Put

One sentence about building things, taken apart

HomeFounders and teams

Hiring for what someone knows, not what their papers say

A degree is a proxy for what someone knows. When the knowledge can be tested directly, the proxy adds little.

When I’m hiring, I don’t look for credentials, I look for knowledge.

Aza Raskin

A diploma tells an employer where someone studied. It says much less about what they can do on a Tuesday afternoon with a real problem. Aza Raskin’s own path explains his preference for the second. The son of Jef Raskin, who started the Macintosh project at Apple, he co-founded a small interface company called Humanized, joined Mozilla as a creative lead on Firefox, and in 2011 was starting a health company. In interface design, what matters is visible in the work: a portfolio, a prototype, a way of explaining a problem.

The research on hiring broadly agrees with him. A widely cited 1998 review by Frank Schmidt and John Hunter, covering decades of studies, found that work-sample tests and measures of general ability predicted job performance far better than years of education. Asking a candidate to do a small piece of the real job tells an employer more than the name of their university. In design that might be a short critique of an existing product; in engineering, a few hours spent fixing a real bug; in sales, a mock call with a skeptical buyer. Each shows how the person thinks under the conditions the job will actually present.

For a startup this is also a practical advantage. Large companies compete for candidates with the best credentials. A small company that can recognize knowledge without them, such as a self-taught programmer with good open source work, can hire people the others overlooked. Much of the early web was built by people like that, who learned to program from books and manuals rather than in a classroom.

The line has clear limits. In medicine, law, accounting and engineering that affects public safety, the credential is a legal requirement and often a fair summary of training that cannot be checked in an interview. And when a founder cannot judge a field, credentials are a reasonable shortcut, since assessing knowledge requires having some. A founder hiring a first lawyer or accountant is better off trusting the qualification and checking references than improvising a test.