Skip to the page

Plainly Put

One sentence about building things, taken apart

HomeExecution

Impossible until somebody does it, and sometimes still impossible

Achievements that once looked impossible tend to look obvious afterwards. That does not make every impossible-sounding plan merely early.

Everything’s impossible until somebody does it.

Unattributed; often credited to Bruce Wayne

The line circulates on posters and mugs under the name of Bruce Wayne, and the original post credited it to him. No one has found it in a Batman film, television episode or widely read comic, and it is best treated as anonymous. The thought itself is very old. Pliny the Elder, writing his Natural History in the first century, observed that many things are judged impossible before they are actually done.

The best-known modern example comes from running. For years many people treated a mile in under four minutes as beyond human ability. In May 1954 Roger Bannister ran it in 3:59.4. Six weeks later John Landy ran faster, and within a few years the barrier had been broken many times. The physical limit had not moved; the belief about it had, and once one person showed the way others found it too.

Business history has similar stories, where an established industry insisted that something could not be done and a newcomer did it. Cheap long-distance air travel, overnight parcel delivery across a continent, and search engines that ranked the entire web were all called unrealistic by people who knew the field well. After the fact they look inevitable.

What changed in those cases was rarely a single breakthrough. It was usually a different set of assumptions about cost, scale or how customers would behave, which the incumbents had not questioned because their own business depended on the old ones.

That is the useful part of the line. Experts tend to extrapolate from how things are done now, and they are often wrong about what a different method can achieve. A founder who hears “impossible” should ask whether it means forbidden by physics or only never done this way.

Most of the time it means something closer to the first. Patent offices long ago stopped examining perpetual-motion machines on the same terms as other inventions because none has ever worked. For every Bannister there were many athletes who believed in a record they never broke, and for every airline that made flying cheap there were others that went bankrupt trying. The line only remembers the successes.

The honest version is conditional. Some things are impossible until somebody does them. Others are impossible, full stop, and the difference usually becomes clear only after a careful look at why experts say no. The line is best used to justify that careful look, not to skip it.