Skip to the page

Plainly Put

One sentence about building things, taken apart

HomeMoney

People pay to keep what they like alive

A one-person software business can sell reassurance as much as features. That works for a small, loyal group and not much beyond it.

People will pay for something they like because they want to ensure its future.

Marco Arment

In October 2010, Marco Arment added an optional subscription to Instapaper, the read-later service he had built and was by then running on his own. It cost a dollar a month, and at launch it offered almost nothing a free user lacked apart from switching off ads. The pitch was support: the money would help keep the service running and pay for new features.

Two months later, a leaked slide suggested that Yahoo planned to wind down Delicious, the bookmarking service millions of people had used for years. Many of them moved within days to Pinboard, a small paid alternative run by one developer, Maciej Cegłowski. Pinboard charged a one-time fee that rose as more people signed up. For users who had just learned what a free service’s future could look like, the fee read as a promise that this one would last.

Both cases fit Arment’s line. When a product is free, its future depends on a business model the user cannot see and does not control. Paying changes that. The user becomes the business model, and a small, steady payment is a way of voting for the product to continue.

For a founder, the practical lesson is to charge from the start where possible, and to say plainly what the money is for. A product that has always been free finds it hard to ask for money later, while one that has been paid from day one can point to its customers as the reason it will survive.

The price also filters the audience. People who pay a small amount up front are, on average, the ones who care most about the product, and their requests tend to be a better guide to what should be built next than the requests of casual users.

The limits are real. Most users of a free product never pay, whatever the appeal, and support-driven revenue usually comes from a small share of devoted users. The motive works best when the product is small and personal, when users can picture the person their money reaches and believe it makes a difference. Nobody sends a large company a monthly payment to keep one of its services alive. Goodwill also fades if subscribers see no sign of work being done, which is why a visible stream of improvements matters as much as the original appeal.