Stay committed to the problem, stay loose about the answer
A team that loves its solution defends it past the point where customers have spoken. A team that loves the problem changes the solution and keeps going.
Marry the problem, not the solution.
The phrase circulates widely among product people; here it is credited to Dan Greenberg, co-founder of the San Francisco advertising startup Sharethrough. It is advice about attachment. Founders fall in love with what they build, and love makes it hard to hear that the thing is wrong. Committing instead to the problem keeps the loyalty and moves it somewhere safer.
PayPal is a good example. Its founders started in 1998 with software for sending money between Palm Pilot handheld computers by beaming it through infrared ports. The problem was moving money between people easily. The Palm Pilot was only one possible solution, and a narrow one. When the team noticed that the email-based version of the service, built almost as a demonstration, was growing much faster, they shifted to it. Loyalty to the problem let them drop the product they had started with.
The line fails in a few ways. Some problems are real but not solvable profitably yet, and a team married to one can spend years waiting for the technology or the market to arrive. A team’s skills are also often tied to a solution: a group of hardware engineers cannot easily become a software company because the problem calls for software.
And sometimes the solution comes first. In 1968 a 3M chemist named Spencer Silver developed an adhesive that stuck lightly and peeled off cleanly. For years nobody knew what it was for. A colleague, Art Fry, eventually used it to keep bookmarks in his hymn book, and the Post-it note went on sale in 1980. That product came from staying loyal to a solution until a problem turned up.
The practical reading is to know which kind of company one is running. Most startups are problem companies and should hold their products loosely. Research labs and some technology companies are solution companies and do better keeping the invention and searching for uses.