Execution decides, and sometimes the idea decides first
The first social network with momentum lost to better executors. A flawless execution of the wrong idea lost too.
It’s not about ideas. It’s about making ideas happen.
Scott Belsky’s book came out in April 2010 with half its argument in the title: Making Ideas Happen. Belsky co-founded Behance, a network for creative professionals, and its think tank and conference, 99U, take their name from Thomas Edison’s line that genius is one percent inspiration and ninety-nine percent perspiration. The sentence above serves as 99U’s motto, and the book is a long case for it drawn from interviews with productive creative people and teams.
Much of the book is about habits rather than inspiration. Belsky’s method sorts everything that comes out of a meeting into action steps, reference material and ideas kept for later, and insists that every action step start with a verb and have an owner. It sounds clerical, and that is deliberate. His observation was that most ideas die in the space between a good meeting and a Monday morning, when nobody has written down who does what next.
The recent history of social networking supports him. Friendster had the concept and the early crowd in 2003, and its pages slowed to a crawl as it grew. Users drifted to MySpace, and Facebook has since grown past both by handling growth one campus at a time and keeping the site fast. The idea of connecting friends online was available to everyone; the companies that won were the ones that kept the service working while it grew.
The line breaks down when the idea itself is wrong. Iridium spent billions of dollars putting a network of sixty-six satellites into orbit so that a phone could work anywhere on earth, and the engineering was a remarkable achievement. The service launched in 1998 and the company filed for bankruptcy the following year. The handsets were large and the calls expensive, and ordinary mobile networks had spread quickly enough that few people needed a phone that worked in the middle of the ocean. No amount of execution could fix the choice of market.
That case sharpens the sentence rather than overturning it. Ideas matter enough to test cheaply before committing to them, and very little beyond that. Once an idea has survived a cheap test, almost everything that follows depends on the dull machinery Belsky writes about: next steps, owners, deadlines and the discipline to keep going through the middle of a project when the excitement has worn off.