Skepticism comes with anything new, so read it carefully
Doubt is guaranteed for anything unprecedented. That is exactly why it carries so little information.
Lots of people were skeptical, but that’s always true when you do something that hasn’t been done before.
In the summer of 2005 a new kind of investor funded eight startups at once, gave each a small amount of money, and asked the founders to spend three months in Cambridge, Massachusetts, working next to each other. Most of the founders were in their early twenties. Y Combinator had no track record, and its model of funding many tiny companies in a batch did not resemble how venture capital was supposed to work. Jessica Livingston, one of its four founders, was 34 when it started.
She wrote the line in a January 2011 essay on her site, What Stops Female Founders?, looking back at that beginning. The essay’s larger subject is why fewer women start companies, and part of her answer concerns the reaction a founder gets when announcing a plan that does not fit anyone’s expectations. People doubted Y Combinator for the same reason. Nothing like it existed, so there was nothing to point to.
Six years later the doubts look quaint. Y Combinator has funded hundreds of companies, and its batches include Dropbox and Airbnb. Other firms now copy the model in cities around the world. The skeptics of 2005 were answering the question “has this worked before?”, and for anything new the answer to that question is always no.
That is the useful reading of the line. Skepticism toward a new idea is close to guaranteed, which means its presence says very little about whether the idea is good. A founder who hears doubt and concludes the idea is weak is reading noise. The same founder should not conclude the opposite, either. Ideas that have not been done before include many that have not been done because they do not work, and they draw the same skepticism as the good ones. Doubt arrives either way.
What separates the two is the content of the objections. Generic doubt, of the “nobody does it this way” kind, can mostly be set aside, since it would apply to any new thing. Specific doubt deserves attention, such as a claim that a particular cost will be too high or that a certain type of customer will not pay. Specific objections can be tested, often cheaply. Some of the doubts about Y Combinator in 2005 were of this kind: that founders barely out of college could not build real companies, and that such small investments could not buy enough time to matter. Both claims could be checked. Running the first summer and watching what the companies did settled questions that no amount of argument could, and each later batch added evidence.
The cost of skepticism is also uneven. Well-connected founders can shrug it off because they have other sources of support. Founders who already face doubt about who they are, which was Livingston’s concern in that essay, get a second layer of it when they propose something unusual, and that can be enough to stop them before they start. For them the line works as reassurance: the doubt is the normal price of novelty, paid by everyone who tries something new.
What the line asks for is modest. Expect doubt, and do not mistake it for a verdict. Sort the objections that would greet any new idea from the ones aimed at this particular idea, then go and test the second group as fast as possible, because those are the ones that might be right.