Research does not make products bland; bad questions do
Asking customers to design a product produces an average of their guesses. That argues for better research, and the CrunchPad shows conviction is no substitute.
Customer research produces bland products. We’re producing a piece of art.
In July 2008 Michael Arrington, the founder of TechCrunch, wrote that he wanted a simple, cheap touchscreen tablet for browsing the web, and that since nobody made one he would build it. The project, called the CrunchPad, was driven by his own taste rather than by surveys. The line is credited to him from that period, though its exact source has not been traced. It describes the kind of product he had in mind: a coherent object shaped by a clear point of view, not a list of features gathered from focus groups.
The criticism of research has something to it. Asked what they want, customers tend to describe small improvements to what they already use, and a product built by averaging their answers pleases nobody strongly. Many of the products people love most came from a designer’s conviction.
The CrunchPad itself is a caution, though. At the end of November 2009 Arrington announced that the project was dead after a falling out with Fusion Garage, the Singapore company building the device. Fusion Garage announced its own version, the JooJoo, a week later, and when it shipped the following spring it sold poorly. In between, in January 2010, Apple announced the iPad, and the market Arrington had imagined arrived with someone else’s product in it. Apple is known for trusting its designers over focus groups, so the iPad in a sense proved Arrington’s point about conviction while his own device never reached a shop.
Conviction did not make the CrunchPad fail, but it did not protect it either. The problems were partnership, manufacturing and money, which a clear vision does not solve.
The real fault the line points at is research that asks the wrong questions. Asking people what features they want produces bland answers. Asking what they do, what annoys them and what they have given up on produces material a designer can use. Good research informs a point of view; it does not replace one.