Skip to the page

Plainly Put

One sentence about building things, taken apart

HomeProduct

Profit follows customers and staff, when it follows at all

Chasing a number directly tends to corrupt the work that produces it. The ordering still leaves someone paying.

Success and profitability are outcomes of focusing on customers and employees, not objectives.

Jack Ma

In February this year Alibaba.com disclosed that more than two thousand of its paying supplier accounts had been used to defraud buyers, and that around a hundred of its own sales staff had helped those sellers get onto the site. The chief executive and the chief operating officer both resigned. Jack Ma described the decision as a matter of protecting the trust of the site’s customers, whatever it cost the quarter.

The episode is a fair test of his line, because it shows both halves. Salespeople with revenue targets had treated the number as the goal, and in chasing it they damaged the thing that produced the number in the first place: buyers’ confidence that a listed supplier was real. When profit becomes the objective, the people nearest to it find ways to hit the target that erode the business underneath.

Ma has long described Alibaba’s priorities as customers first, employees second and shareholders third. The reasoning is that satisfied customers produce revenue, and capable, well-treated staff produce satisfied customers. Profit is what shows up at the end of that chain if the chain works. Targeting it directly is like trying to be happy by thinking about happiness.

The idea is sound as a guide to attention. Most people in a company cannot move profit directly. They can answer a customer properly, fix a defect, train a new colleague. Measuring those things, and treating profit as a check on whether the whole system works, keeps attention on work people can actually do.

It is less sound as a guarantee. Plenty of companies are loved by customers and staff and still lose money, because their prices are too low or their costs too high. Profit is an outcome, but of more than care. Pricing, cost control and choosing a market where people can pay are decisions in their own right, and a company that treats them as side effects will find the outcome never arrives.

The ordering also has costs that fall on somebody. Earlier this year Ma moved ownership of Alipay, the group’s payment business, out of the structure its major shareholders held stakes in, citing Chinese rules on foreign ownership of payment firms. Yahoo, one of those shareholders, said it had not been properly informed, and the dispute took months to settle. Whatever the merits, it was a clear case of shareholders coming third, and they did not enjoy it.

For a founder the useful part is the instruction about attention. Decide which measures of customer and staff health lead to revenue in this particular business, watch those closely, and read the profit figure as a verdict on the whole model. Just avoid assuming the verdict will be kind because the intentions were good.