Skip to the page

Plainly Put

One sentence about building things, taken apart

HomeExecution

Choose the option the team actually wants to do

Threadless grew out of a forum contest two friends ran for fun. Its co-founder's rule for decisions makes sense against that history, up to the point where the necessary work begins.

I try not to make any decisions that I’m not excited about.

Jake Nickell

Threadless began in 2000 as a side project between two members of an online forum for designers. Jake Nickell and Jacob DeHart put in $500 each, asked the forum to submit T-shirt designs, let the members vote, and printed the winners. The prize for the first contest was two free shirts. Nothing in that arrangement looked like a plan for a large company, and for years it grew the way hobbies grow, because the people running it wanted to see what happened next.

Read against that history, Nickell’s rule is less about mood than about selection. A founder makes hundreds of small calls a week: which feature to build next, whose meeting to take, which market to try. Most of them are reversible, and none of them comes with enough data. Excitement works as a tiebreaker in that fog. It points at the options where the founder already has energy to spend, and energy is the scarce input in a small company. A decision taken without enthusiasm tends to be carried out without it as well, and the result shows up months later as a launch that drifted or an integration nobody finished.

The rule also protects a company’s character. Threadless kept the community vote at its center because the founders cared about it more than about the obvious alternative of hiring in-house designers and running an ordinary apparel line. A more “sensible” decision process might well have drifted toward the ordinary line, which is the one business that had no reason to exist, since better-funded clothing brands already ran it.

Where the rule breaks is in the decisions nobody could be excited about. Letting an employee go, closing a product that a few loyal customers still use, renegotiating with a supplier who has missed three deliveries, paying for an audit: these arrive whether or not anyone feels good about them, and postponing them until enthusiasm appears is how small problems become large ones. A founder who applies the filter literally will quietly defer the unpleasant work or hand it down, and someone else in the company inherits it.

There is a second failure. Excitement is a feeling, and feelings can be produced on demand by a persuasive partner, a flattering investor, or the plain novelty of a new idea set against the grind of an old one. A founder who follows excitement without checking it can end up starting a great deal and finishing little.

The workable version is narrower than the sentence. Among options that the company can afford and that customers actually want, pick the one the team is eager to do, because that one will be done well. For everything outside that set, the obligation stands whether or not it is enjoyable. As a guide to choosing what to pursue, the line holds up. As a reason to avoid what has to be done, it does not.