Skip to the page

Plainly Put

One sentence about building things, taken apart

HomeProduct

User experience decays unless someone keeps working on it

A product that was simple at launch gets complicated one reasonable feature at a time. Keeping it usable is maintenance, not a project.

You should always be working hard on user experience. Not just at the beginning.

Ryan Carson

Ryan Carson ran Carsonified, a British company known for its web conferences, and in 2010 was building an online training service for web designers and developers. At the dConstruct conference in Brighton that September he questioned whether “UX professional” was a real job title, which set off a long argument among designers. His line here, credited to him though its original setting has not been traced, sits comfortably with that position: if user experience is everyone’s ongoing work, it looks less like a specialty to be hired once.

The point it makes is about time. Most teams put their best design effort into the first release. They study the flow, test it with a few people and trim what confuses. Then the product ships, customers ask for things, and features accumulate. Each addition is reasonable. Together they bury the original flow under options, settings and new menu items, and the product that once needed no instructions now needs a help center.

The decay is easy to miss from inside. The team knows where everything is. New users do not, and the first place the damage shows is in sign-up and activation numbers, which drift down slowly enough that nobody connects them to any single change.

Continuous work on the experience means treating that decay like any other maintenance. Someone watches new users try the product at regular intervals. Old features get reviewed and, sometimes, removed. The first-run experience is redesigned as the product grows, because the version that suited three features does not suit thirty.

The line needs one qualification. Working hard on user experience does not mean redesigning constantly. Facebook’s changes to its home page drew organized protests from users, including a group of hundreds of thousands against the News Feed in 2006, and many of those redesigns were improvements that people still resented because they had learned the old layout. Familiarity is part of the experience. The steady work is mostly small: removing friction, fixing confusing words, keeping new features out of the paths that matter.

It also has to compete with other priorities. For some companies at some stages, the constraint is not the interface at all but distribution, pricing or reliability. A team that polishes screens while the service goes down twice a week has its order wrong. Carson’s advice is about never stopping, which is right. It is not about always putting the experience first.