Skip to the page

Plainly Put

One sentence about building things, taken apart

HomeProduct

Customer money buys time without selling any of the company

A paying customer funds the company, tests the product and gives up no equity. Some products cannot reach a customer without outside money first.

The best investor is your customer.

Esther Dyson

Esther Dyson has spent decades as an analyst and angel investor, publishing the technology newsletter Release 1.0 and backing young companies in the United States and Eastern Europe. The line is credited to her in collections of startup advice; the occasion on which she first said it is not recorded. Coming from an investor, it is a useful concession.

A customer’s money does three things at once. It funds the company. It proves that someone values the product enough to pay. And it costs no equity, board seat or reporting obligation. An investor’s money does only the first, and at a price. A company that can grow on revenue keeps control of its direction and learns faster, because every sale and every refusal teaches something. Customers also judge the product on a shorter cycle than investors do. An investor reviews progress every quarter or at the next round; a customer decides every month whether to keep paying, and the decision arrives whether the founders are ready for it or not.

Plenty of software firms have worked this way. 37signals built Basecamp in 2004 as a tool for its own client work, began charging for it, and grew into a profitable company without venture funding. GitHub charges for private repositories and has grown on that income since it launched in 2008. Pre-orders work on the same principle: a product sold before it exists is funded by the people who want it. Kickstarter, launched in 2009, has turned that into a platform for small creative projects.

The line fails for products that need large sums before any customer can use them. A new drug, a satellite or a manufactured device requires years of spending before the first sale. Social networks and marketplaces often need to be free and very large before anyone will pay for them, which is why Facebook took outside money long before it earned much. In those cases the customer still matters as the eventual investor, but the company has to survive on other people’s capital until it arrives.

Customer funding also has its own strings. A company that depends on one or two large clients can find its roadmap set by them, drifting from product into custom work. Small customers are better investors in this sense: each one matters less, so none can steer the company alone.

The practical reading is to ask, for any spending, whether a customer could fund it. Where one can, charging early gives the company money, evidence and independence. Where none can, outside capital is the honest answer, and the job is to reach the point where customers take over as soon as possible.