The route to one good idea runs through many bad ones
The attribution is uncertain but the pattern is well supported: people who produce more ideas tend to produce more good ones.
To have a great idea, have a lot of them.
The line is usually printed under Thomas Edison’s name, and it suits him. His laboratory at Menlo Park tested thousands of materials in the search for a lasting light-bulb filament before settling on carbonized bamboo, and he ended his career with more than a thousand American patents. No letter, notebook or interview has been produced in which he says these words, though, and a similar sentence is also credited to the chemist Linus Pauling. The saying is best treated as anonymous advice that fits Edison’s methods.
The idea behind it has good support. The psychologist Dean Keith Simonton, who studied the output of scientists and composers across careers, found that the people with the most celebrated works also produced the most works overall, including many forgotten ones. Their hit rate was not much higher than their peers’. They simply made more attempts.
In practice this argues for cheap ideas. A product team that brainstorms forty names finds a better name than one that debates three. A founder who writes down every possible customer segment before choosing is more likely to find one that works. The first idea in any session is usually the obvious one, and the good ones tend to come later, after the obvious ones are out of the way.
Volume has a cost when it replaces commitment. A startup cannot pursue a lot of ideas at once. It has to choose one and push it far enough to learn whether it works, which takes months. Founders who keep generating new ideas instead of finishing the current one mistake the pleasure of starting for progress. Having many ideas is useful at the stage of choosing. After that, the valuable skill is the opposite one.
Selection also matters as much as supply. Many ideas are useless without a way of sorting them quickly, whether through small tests, customer conversations or plain arithmetic about the size of a market. Edison’s own lab was organized around testing, not only around imagining, and that is where the saying’s hero earned his reputation.