Skip to the page

Plainly Put

One sentence about building things, taken apart

HomeExecution

Nobody is waiting to steal the idea, with a few exceptions

The fear of theft assumes someone capable is idle and waiting. That is almost never true, and the exceptions are easy to name.

Tell anyone and everyone your idea without fear they’re going to steal it.

Aaron Patzer

Aaron Patzer built the first version of Mint largely by himself, after growing tired of personal finance software that expected him to type in every purchase. Then, against his own instinct, he described it to nearly everyone he could reach: friends, former colleagues, strangers at events. Plenty of them were unimpressed. The conversations still paid for themselves. They led to advisers, to early investors and to a clearer idea of what people would trust with their bank passwords. Mint won the TechCrunch40 competition in 2007 and was sold to Intuit two years later for $170 million.

Another page here looks at why an idea kept private has not been tested. This line invites a more practical question: who, exactly, would steal it? Consider the candidates. A stranger at a party has a job and no time. A skilled engineer has ideas of her own and prefers them. An established company has a roadmap full for the next year and a process that takes months to approve anything new. The people able to copy an idea quickly are almost always busy with something they care about more.

Execution is also harder to copy than a description. A pitch of two sentences leaves out the thousand decisions that make a product work, and those decisions are where the value lies. Patzer’s own competitors had years of head start and still left the space open.

The exceptions are real, though, and worth knowing. When the idea is a small feature that a large platform could add in a few weeks, telling that platform’s employees is a risk. Developers of Mac software have a word for being made obsolete when Apple builds their product into the operating system, after the company’s search tool Sherlock absorbed the features of a popular third-party app in 2002. Inventions that depend on a patent should be filed before they are discussed widely, since public disclosure can limit patent rights. And a founder negotiating with a potential acquirer or partner should share details at the pace of the deal.

Outside those cases, silence mostly costs the founder the feedback, contacts and early customers that talking would have brought, in exchange for protection against a thief who rarely exists.