Skip to the page

Plainly Put

One sentence about building things, taken apart

HomeFounders and teams

Measuring success in fun, and who else gets counted

Threadless began as a side project run for the pleasure of it. Its founder's measure of success follows from that, and has limits he could afford to ignore.

Success is defined in units of fun. It’s all about being happy.

Jake Nickell

In 2000 Jake Nickell, fresh from winning an online T-shirt design contest, put about a thousand dollars together with a friend, Jacob DeHart, and started a site where people could submit shirt designs and vote on which ones got printed. It was a hobby for years. Threadless grew into a real company without the usual startup machinery, taking only a minority investment in 2006, and remains unusual in how much it still looks like a community that happens to sell shirts.

Coming from someone with that history, the line is less naive than it sounds. Enjoyment is a reasonable test for a founder deciding how to spend years of work. A founder who dreads the work will either quit or run the company badly, and one who enjoys it has a source of persistence that money does not provide. Threadless’s own growth came from people who liked what they were doing: designers submitting for the fun of it and customers voting because they enjoyed the game.

The measure has two problems. The first is that fun is easiest to count for the person at the top. A founder can find a company delightful while the warehouse staff find it exhausting, or while contributors do creative work for small returns. A company that measures success in fun has to ask whose fun, and whether the people packing the orders would score it the same way.

The second is that fun and money are not independent. A company that runs out of cash stops being enjoyable quickly, and so do layoffs. Threadless could treat happiness as the goal partly because it was profitable early and never had to meet the expectations of large outside investors. Most startups have less room.

Read with those limits, the line is a sound check rather than a strategy. If the work stopped being enjoyable for everyone involved, something has gone wrong, even if the revenue says otherwise.