Skip to the page

Plainly Put

One sentence about building things, taken apart

HomeMoney

Building on land someone else owns

A platform can hand a young company millions of users. It can also change one rule and take most of them away.

You cannot rest the fate of your business and your personal livelihood on top of another person’s platform.

Spencer Fry

Spencer Fry co-founded Carbonmade in 2005, a service that hosts online portfolios for designers, illustrators and photographers. Its customers find it, sign up and pay it directly each month. That is a plain business model, and it gives Fry’s warning its point of view: the company’s revenue depends on nobody’s permission but its customers’. The line circulates under his name; its original setting has not been traced.

The last few years have supplied plenty of examples of the alternative. Developers who built applications inside Facebook grew quickly on the network’s feeds and notifications, then watched their traffic fall each time Facebook tightened the rules on what apps could post. Even Zynga, the largest of them, spent the spring of 2010 in a tense negotiation with Facebook over payments before the two signed a five-year agreement. Twitter bought Tweetie, the popular iPhone client, in April 2010 and made it the official app, and every company selling another Twitter client learned that the platform could become its competitor overnight. Apple has rejected iPhone applications for reasons developers could not predict, including Google’s own voice calling app in 2009. Sites that live on search traffic know that a change to Google’s ranking can halve their income in a week.

The danger is not that platforms are malicious. It is that their interests and those of the businesses built on them overlap only partly, and when they diverge the platform decides. A company whose customers, data and payments all pass through someone else’s system has, in effect, a single customer who can change the terms at will.

The line should not be read as advice to avoid platforms, which is impossible. Every online business runs on someone’s servers, takes payment through someone’s card network and reaches users through someone’s browser or phone. Many of the fastest-growing companies of the past five years, Zynga included, began by using a platform’s distribution when it was open and generous. That was a sensible choice.

The useful distinction is between using a platform and resting on it. A business that uses Facebook to find customers but collects their email addresses, bills them itself and keeps their data can move if it has to. A business whose only relationship with its users is a platform account cannot. The questions to ask are specific: if the platform cut this company off tomorrow, which customers could still be reached, and how much of the revenue would survive? If the answers are none and nothing, the founder’s livelihood belongs to someone else.

Diversifying costs something, in time and in growth forgone. For a small company the cheapest insurance is usually the plainest: own the customer relationship and the billing, even when a platform delivers most of the traffic.