A good idea still needs a route to its users
Hoffman means something specific by strategy: how the product reaches a very large audience without running out of money on the way.
Good ideas need good strategy to realize their potential.
The sentence comes from a guest column Reid Hoffman wrote in April 2009 describing the three tests he applies before investing. The first asks whether the product can reach a massive audience through some distribution advantage. The second asks whether it offers something clearly different from what already exists. The third asks whether the company can get there without burning through huge amounts of capital. His conclusion was that a company passing all three has time to find its business model, since most original plans change anyway.
That definition matters, because “strategy” often calls to mind a long document full of market-size charts. Hoffman means something narrower and harder: a specific answer to how the product will get in front of millions of people. LinkedIn, which he founded in 2003, grew slowly at first. It kept growing because each member’s invitations brought in colleagues, and because public profiles gave people a reason to maintain them and a way for others to find them through search. Those were strategic choices about distribution, and they compounded over years.
Many good products fail on exactly this point. A useful tool that must be sold one customer at a time by an expensive sales team, to a market too small to repay the cost, is a good idea with no route to scale. The product can be excellent and the company can still die. Channels also change with time. In the years when LinkedIn was growing, email invitations and search traffic were cheap ways to reach people. As more companies crowd into the same channels they get expensive, and a route that worked for an earlier company can fail for a later one copying it.
There are also companies that stumbled into their route rather than planning it. Yelp found its audience through user reviews, a side feature its founders had not built the company around. In those cases the strategy was recognized afterward and then pursued deliberately. Early founders should not mistake a missing plan for a missing future.
The practical version of the line is a question to ask of any idea early: what, specifically, will carry it to a large number of people, and what will that cost? A convincing answer is worth more than a longer description of the idea itself.