Skip to the page

Plainly Put

One sentence about building things, taken apart

HomeFounders and teams

Acting brilliant is the slow road to being seen as brilliant

Confidence can borrow a reputation for a few months. The work has to repay the loan.

The key to getting a reputation for being brilliant is actually being brilliant, not just acting like you are.

Seth Godin

Almost every company of any size has someone who is difficult and kept anyway: the engineer who belittles questions, the designer who refuses to explain, the salesman who ignores process and closes deals. Colleagues put up with it because the work is good. Seth Godin’s point, made at the end of a November 2010 post on arrogance as a bug in signal processing, is about what happens next. People nearby start to treat the rudeness as the signal. If the gifted ones are arrogant, then arrogance might pass for being gifted.

It works for a while, which is why it spreads. A confident manner reads as competence in a short meeting. Founders who speak in certainties often raise money more easily than founders who hedge, and conviction in the room is part of what many investors say they look for. A reputation can be borrowed from style for months.

What the line says is that the loan comes due. A reputation for brilliance rests on work other people can see and check: code that runs and forecasts that turn out right. Acting the part without the output lasts until someone looks at the output. In a startup that moment arrives quickly, because the team is small and everyone’s work is visible to everyone else.

An honest reading goes a step past Godin’s framing. Being brilliant is necessary for the reputation, but it is not always enough. Plenty of very good engineers and researchers are overlooked because they do not explain their work, do not claim credit, or work on problems their managers do not understand. The claim is that acting cannot replace substance. It does not follow that substance gets noticed on its own. Some self-presentation is part of doing the job, as long as it describes real work.

Nor does the arrogance always come from pretenders. Some genuinely brilliant people are also unpleasant, and their output sometimes justifies keeping them. The cost tends to show up elsewhere: good people who leave, and junior staff who stop pointing out mistakes. The star’s reputation survives while the team around it thins.

For a founder hiring early employees, the practical test is to separate manner from evidence. Ask what the person built, look at it, and talk to people who worked beside them. Confidence backed by that record is fine. Confidence standing in for it is the pattern Godin was warning about.

For someone building their own name, the advice is plainer. Put the effort into the work, then describe it accurately and without decoration. The first part is what the line demands. The second is what it leaves out.